“The creature was made subject to vanity not willingly”: The controversy over the influence of the Fall on living nature and the rise of paleontology

Authors

  • Alexander V. Khramov Paleontological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 123, ul. Profsoyuznaya, Moscow, 117647, Russian Federation; Saints Cyril and Methodius Institute for Postgraduate Studies, 4/2, ul. Pyatnitskaya, Moscow, 115035, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6888-5162

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu28.2022.303

Abstract

This paper deals with discussions sparked by the scientific advances of paleontology in the first half of the 19th century on whether predation and animal death should be linked to the Fall of man. The history of the belief in paradisiacal vegetarianism and animal peace, which could be traced back to the writings of Early Church fathers, is briefly discussed. The paper discusses the argumentation of W. Buckland, E. Hitchcock, H. Miller, and other men of science and theologians, who accepted the fact, which became evident from the fossil record, that death and predation prevailed in the living nature from the beginning, and struggled to conceive it in the Christian terms. Light is shed on the early pictorial representations of prehistoric life, which accentuated ferocity of the primeval world in stark contrast to the traditional view on the prelapsarian harmony between animals. The attitudes of those who persisted in defending the belief in peaceful animal relationships in paradise despite of findings of paleontology are explored. The main exponents of the latter view could be found among the “scriptural geologists”, the early predecessors of presentday Young Earth creationists. The attempt by the Scottish theologian W. Gillespie to explain the existence of predation in prehistoric animals by the Fall of Satan is reviewed. It can be concluded that the revision of Christian doctrine of the earthly paradise had been well underway in the pre-Darwinian age and was accomplished with the triumph of evolutionism.

Keywords:

the Fall, evolution, paradise, six days of creation, Genesis, science and religion

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References


References

Andreini G. B. (1617) L’Adamo. Milano, Bordoni G.

Anonymous author (1856) The Creative Week: Being a secular exposition of the mosaic record of creation. Edinburgh, Maclachlan and Stewart.

Basil the Great, St (1972) “The second talk on man by Saint Basil the Great”, in Zhurnal Moskovskoi patriarkhii, no. 3, pp. 33–40. (In Russian)

Bede, St (2008) On Genesis. Liverpool, Liverpool University Press.

Boyd H. S. (1817) “On cosmogony”, in Philosophical Magazine, vol. 50, pp. 375–378.

Buckland W. (1836) Geology and mineralogy considered with reference to natural theology. London, W. Pickering.

Buckland W. (1839) An inquiry whether the sentence of death pronounced at the Fall of man included the whole animal creation, or was restricted to the human race. London, John Murray.

Bugg G. (1826) Scriptural geology, or Geological phenomena, consistent only with the literal interpretation of the sacred Scriptures. In 2 vols, vol. 1. London, Hatchard and son.

Bugg G. (1827) Scriptural geology, or Geological phenomena, consistent only with the literal interpretation of the sacred Scriptures. In 2 vols, vol. 2. London, Hatchard and son.

Conte A. L. (2020) “Carlo Antonio and the bottega Procaccini”, in Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte, Bd. 83, S. 7–32.

Dmitrieva O. V. (2016) “Virtues of the silkworm: Poetical entomology of Thomas Moffet and intellectual patronage of Sidney family”, in Art and culture of Renaissance and Early Modern Europe: Collection of works in honour of V. M. Volodarsky, pp. 40–54. Rus. ed. Moscow; St Petersburg, Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ Publ. (In Russian)

Ephrem the Syrian, St (1994) Selected prose works. Washington, The Catholic University of America Press.

Gillespie W. (1859) The theology of geologists. Edinburgh, Adam and Charles Black.

Gisborne T. (1818) The testimony of natural theology to Christianity. London, T. Cadell and W. Davies.

Gloag P. T. (1859) The primeval world: A treatise on the relations of geology to theology. Edinburgh, T. & T. Clark.

Grosseteste R. (1996) On the Six Days of Creation. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Hawkins T. (1840) The Book of the Great Sea-Dragons, Ichthyosauri and Plesiosauri. London, W. Pickering.

Herrin A. K. (2014) “Pioneers of the printed Paradise: Maarten de Vos, Jan Sadeler I and emblematic natural history in the late sixteenth century”, in K. A. E. Enenkel, P. J. Smith, eds. Zoology in early modern culture, pp. 329–400. Leiden, Brill.

Hitchcock E. (1842) Elementary geology. New York, Dayton and Newman.

Hitchcock E. (1851) The religion of geology and its connected science. Boston, Phillips, Sampson and co.

Irenaeus of Lyons, St (2008) Against heresies. The demonstration of the Apostolic preaching. Rus. ed. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Olega Abyshko Publ. (In Russian)

Jolly P. H. (1997) Made in God’s Image? Eve and Adam in the Genesis Mosaics at San Marco, Venice. Berkeley, University of California Press.

Kessler H. L. (1971) “Hic Homo Formatur: The Genesis frontispieces of the Carolingian Bibles”, in The Art Bulletin, vol. 53, pp. 143–160.

Khramov A. V. (2018) “Attraction of the opposites: Reception of the theory of evolution in young earth creationists”, in Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Ser. 1. Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie, no. 76, pp. 59–76. (In Russian)

Khramov A. V. (2019) “Theistic evolutionism and the problem of theodicy”, in Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Ser. 1. Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie, no. 83, pp. 26–44. (In Russian)

Khramov A. V. (2019) “The Days of Creation and geologic time in the british theological and scientific thought of the first half of the 19th century”, in Vestnik Ekaterinburgskoi dukhovnoi seminarii, no. 2 (26), pp. 75–97. (In Russian)

Kirby W. (1835) On the history, habits and instincts of animals. In 2 vols, vol. 1. London, W. Pickering.

Konowitz E. (1984) “The program of the Carrand Diptych”, in The Art Bulletin, vol. 66, pp. 484–488.

Lovyagin E. (1860) “On hypotheses of newest geologists contradicting the Scripture”, in Strannik, no. 5, pp. 334–371. (In Russian)

Maguire H. (1987) “Adam and the animals: Allegory and the literal sense in early Christian art”, in Dumbarton Oaks Papers, vol. 41, pp. 363–373.

Manucci F., Romano M. (2022) “Reviewing the iconography and the central role of ‘paleoart’: Four centuries of geo-palaeontological art”, in Historical Biology. https://doi.org/10.1080/08912963.2021.2017919

Miller H. (1857) The testimony of the rocks; or geology in its bearings on the two theologies, natural and revealed. Boston, Gould and Lincoln.

Milton J. (2007) Paradise lost. Rus. ed. Moscow, Eksmo Publ. (In Russian)

Minnis A. (2016) From Eden to eternity: Creations of Paradise in the later Middle Ages. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press.

[Murray J.] (1839) “Dr. Buckland’s geological sermon”, in The Christian Observer, no. 19, pp. 400–401.

Nekrasova I. A. (2019). “The religious theatre of Giovanni Battista Andreini: L’Adamo and two Magdalena”, in Vestnik Akademii Russkogo baleta im. A. Ia. Vaganovoi, no. 1, pp. 191–215. (In Russian)

Pye-Smith J. (1840) On the relation between the Holy Scriptures and some parts of geological sciences. New York, D. Appleton and company.

Rikken M. (2014) “Exotic animal painting by Jan Brueghel the Elder and Roelant Savery”, in K. A. E. Enenkel, P. J. Smith, eds. Zoology in early modern culture, pp. 401–433. Leiden, Brill.

Rudwick M. J. S. (1992) Scenes from deep time: Early pictorial representations of the prehistoric world. Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.

Theophilus of Antioch, St (1988) “To Autolycus”, in Early Church Fathers, pp. 458–521. Brussels, Zhizn’ s Bogom Publ. (In Russian)

Thomas Aquinas (2005). Summa Theologica. Part 1. Questions 75–119. Rus. ed. Kiev, Nika-tsentr Publ. (In Russian)

Weitzmann K. (1999) The illustrations in the manuscripts of the Septuagiant. In 3 vols, vol. 2: Octateuch. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Downloads

Published

2022-09-22

Issue

Vol. 4 No. 3 (2022)

Section

Research

License

Articles of "Issues of Theology" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.