Specificity of Palamite theology, its origins and later reception
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu28.2021.308Abstract
A conversation with Dmitry Biryukov, Doctor of Philosophy, a researcher of the work of the late Byzantine theologian Gregory Palamas (1296–1359), is devoted to a discussion of the peculiarities of the doctrine of this authoritative church teacher, as well as the reception of his legacy in the 19th–20th centuries after centuries of oblivion. In the course of the conversation, the basic metaphysical scheme of Palamite theology is indicated — the distinction between essence and energies in God; on the one hand, the continuity of this scheme in relation to the theology of the Cappadocian Fathers is traced, and, on the other hand, its novelty is revealed; the origins and parallels of this distinction are discussed, in particular its connection with Christology, as well as the influence of Evagrianism on Palamas; the types of divine energies in the Palamite doctrine are indicated and the question of the difference in theological languages in which the idea of deification (theosis) as a union of man with God is expressed. Particular attention is paid to the concept of “energy” and its various connotations, including those associated with its modern natural science understanding. The philosophical dimension of the theology of Palamas, including in connection with the intellectual culture of his time, is discussed, as well as the relationship of hesychasm as a monastic practice and Palamism as a theological and philosophical doctrine. The concluding part of the conversation, dedicated to the reception of Palamism after centuries of oblivion, traces the history of the study, interpretation and actualization of the teachings of Gregory Palamas over the past two centuries — from Slavophiles to Soviet and contemporary researchers. Particular attention is paid to the so-called neo-Palamism in its various versions — both religious-philosophical and theological.
Keywords:
Gregory Palamas, Palamism, late Byzantine theology, Russian religious philosophy, neo-Palamism, essence and energies in God, deification (theosis)
Downloads
References
Aleksii, bishop (1906) Fourteenth-century Byzantine church mystics. Kazan’, Pravoslavnyi Sobesednik Publ. (In Russian)
Bibikhin V. V. (2010) Energy. Мoscow, Institut filosofii, teologii i istorii sv. Fomy Publ. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2009) “Gregory Palamas”, in Antologiia vostochno-khristianskoi bogoslovskoi mysli. Ortodoksiia i geterodoksiia. In 2 vols. Vol. 2, eds. G. I. Benevich, D. S. Biryukov, pp. 448–466. Мoscow, St. Petersburg, Nikeia Publ. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2009) “The topic of describing a human person through the ‘convergence of features’ in St. Basil the Great and Its Church-Historical and Historical-Philosophical Context”, in Bogoslovskie trudy, iss. 42, pp. 87–109. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Moskovskoi patriarkhii Publ. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2012) “On the treatise ‘Rule of Theology’ by St. Neilos Kabasilas and the theme of the distinction between light and heat of fire by St. Neilos Kabasilas and St. Gregory Palamas”, in EINAI: Problemy filosofii i teologii, no. 2, pp. 423–440. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2017) “The theme of the hierarchy of natural things in Palamitic literature. Part 1: The prehistory of the theme of the hierarchy of being and the emergence of this theme in the Palamitic disputes”, in Konstantinove Listy, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 15–22. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2018) “The Reception of the Palamism in Russian Thought in the Early 20th Century: The Issue of the Philosophical Status of Palamism and Barlaamism, Its Solutions and Context”, in Vestnik Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. 4: Istoriia. Regionovedenie. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia, vol. 23, no. 5, pp. 34–47. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2019) “Taxonomies of beings in the Palamite literature. Part 2: The Palamite doctrine in the context of the previous Byzantine tradition and its reception in the Russian religious thought of the 20th сentury (the philosophy of creativity by Sergei Bulgakov)”, in Konstantinove Listy, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 69–79. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2020) “‘Synergetic Revelation of Reality’: Observations on the prehistory, sources and contents of the notions of ‘symbol’, ‘synergy’, and ‘energy’ in P. A. Florensky in the context of the reception of Palamism in Russian thought in the early 20th century”, in Voprosy filosofii, no. 6, pp. 103–115. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2020) “The Aristotelian paradigm of communion in Byzantine theology: Gregory of Nyssa on human nature as a monad and Gregory Palamas on the impossibility of communion with the divine essence”, in Filosofiia religii: analiticheskie issledovaniia, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 36–58. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2020) “Two thinkers in conversation about Palamism: the sophiological Palamism of Fr. Sergius Bulgakov and the neopalamism of Fr. George Florovsky (1920s)”, in Voprosy bogosloviia, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 13–43. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2021) “Formation of the Palamite doctrine in the letters of Gregory Palamas to Gregory Akindynos and Barlaam of Calabria”, in Pis’ma sviatitelia Grigoriia Palamy k Grigoriiu Akindinu i Varlaamu Kalabriiskomu, pp. 9–52. Kiev, Tserkovshchina Publ. (In Russian)
Biryukov D. S. (2021) “The Reception of Palamism in the Onomatodoxy Legacy of A. F. Losev. Part 1: The Dating of Losev’s article ‘Die Onomatodoxie (russisch ‘Imiaslavie’)’ and the question of the dependence of this article on the onomatodoxical texts of P. A. Florensky ”, in Platonovskie issledovaniia, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 189–202. (In Russian)
Bulgakov S. (2017) The Unfading Light. Contemplations and speculations. Sergiev Posad, Moskovskaia gubernskaia tipografiia I. Ivanova Publ. (In Russian)
El’chenko P. (2021) “Why God created evil, how to save the soul and 17 more difficult questions about Neoplatonism: Interview with the historian of philosophy Svetlana Mesyats”, in Gor’kii. April, 15. Available at: https://gorky.media/context/zachem-bog-sotvoril-zlo-kak-spasti-dushu-i-eshhe-17-neprostyh-voprosov-o-neoplatonizme (accessed: 27.08.2021). (In Russian)
Florovskii G. V. (1928) “Creature and creaturehood”, in Pravoslavnaia mysl’, iss. 1, pp. 176–212. (In Russian)
Georgi Fakrasis (2009) The dispute between St. Gregory Palamas and Gregora the Philosopher. The philosophical and theological foundations of the Palamitic disputes. Transl. by D. A. Pospelov; ed. by D. S. Biryukov. Moscow, Sviataia Gora Afon Publ., Nikeia Publ. (In Russian)
Grigori Palama (1995) Triads in defence of the sacred-silent. Moscow, Kanon Publ. (In Russian)
Isaeva N. V. (1996) The word that creates the world. From Early Vedanta to Kashmir Shaivism: Gaudapada Bhartrihari Abhinavagupta. Moscow, Ladomir Publ. (In Russian)
Kiprian (Kern), Archimandrite (1950) The Anthropology of St. Gregory Palamas. Paris, YMCAPRESS. (In Russian)
Kireevskii I. V. (1979) “On the nature of enlightenment in Europe and its relation to the enlightenment of Russia”, in Kireevskii I. V. Criticism and Aesthetics, pp. 248–293. Мoscow, Iskusstvo Publ. (In Russian)
Krivocheine B. (1936) “La doctrine acketique et theologique de Saint Gregoire Palamas”, in Seminarium Kondakovianum, vol. VIII. Prague, Kondakov Institute Publ.
Losev A. F. (1993) “Onomatodoxy”. Transl. from German, in Voprosy filosofii, no. 9, pp. 52–60. (In Russian)
Medvedev I. P. (1997) Byzantine humanism of the 14th and 15th centuries. St. Petersburg, Aleteia Publ. (In Russian)
Meyendorf I., archpriest (1997) The Life and Works of St. Gregory Palamas: Introduction to the Study. Eds I. P. Medvedev, V. M. Lurie; transl. by G. N. Nachinkin. St. Petersburg, Vizantinorossika Publ. (In Russian)
Meyendorff J. (1959) Introduction à l’étude de Grégoire Palamas (Patristica Sorbonensia, vol. 3). Paris, Éditions du Seuil.
Modest, hegumen (1860) Saint Gregory Palamas, Metropolitan of Thessalonica. A proponent of the Orthodox doctrine of the Light of Tabor and the Acts of God. Kiev, tipografiia A. Gammershmid Publ. (In Russian)
Monк David Disipat (2012) Polemical writings. History and theology of the Palamite disputes. Eds A. I. Solopov, D. S. Biryukov. Мoscow, Nikeia Publ. (In Russian)
Nedetovskii G. (1872) “Barlaam’s heresy”, in Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, vol. 1, pp. 316–357. (In Russian)
Obolevich T. (2020) Myrrha Lot-Borodine. Historian, writer, philosopher, theologian. St. Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriia Publ. (In Russian)
Rigo A. (1989) Monaci esicasti e monaci bogomili. Le accuse di messalianismo e bogomilismo rivolte agli esicasti ed il problema dei rapporti tra esicasmo e bogomilismo (Orientalia venetiana, vol. 2). Firenze, Olschki.
Sokolov I. I. (1913) St Gregory Palamas, Archbishop of Thessalonica. His works and doctrine of isichia. St. Petersburg, izdatel’stvo Sankt-Peterburgskoi dukhovnoi akademii Publ. (In Russian)
Stăniloae D. (1938) Viața și învățătura Sf. Grigorie Palama. Sibiu, [s. n.].
Uspenskii F. I. (1891) Essays on the history of Byzantine education. St. Petersburg, Tipografiia V. S. Balasheva Publ. (In Russian)
Vasilii (Krivoshein), archbishop (2011) “The ascetic and theological teachings of St Gregory Palamas”, in Vasilii (Krivoshein), archbishop. Bogoslovskie trudy, pp. 61–143. Nizhnii Novgorod, Khristianskaia biblioteka Publ. (In Russian)
Zarin S. M. (1907) Asceticism according to Orthodox Christian teaching. Vol. 1: The Essential Positive, book 2: Experiences of Systematic Disclosure of the Issue. St. Petersburg, tipografiia V. F. Kirshbauma Publ. (In Russian)
Zubov V. P. (2004) “<…On energies, hypostases, and essence…>”, in Zubov V. P. Izbrannye trudy po istorii filosofii i estetiki, 1917–1930. Comp. by M. V. Zubova, pp. 33–45. Moscow, Indrik Publ. (In Russian)
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Articles of "Issues of Theology" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
