The problem of free will in Eastern and Western Christianity
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu28.2022.405Abstract
Modern interest in the problem of human free will is largely centered on artificial intellect and transhumanism concepts. However, within a physicalist framework, in contrast with medieval thought, this issue is not considered to belong to the area of metaphysics. The article describes historical features of Eastern and Western approaches to this problem. The contrast between the ancient worldview and the Christian standpoint is discussed, as well as the complicated issue of the autonomy of will in coordination with Providence, which demands antinomic combination of divine omniscience and the optionality of human choice. The nature of this antinomy was understood based on an incorrect description of spiritual and divine worlds by means of a language based on classical logic principles, which include empirical laws of rough matter. It is noted that in Western European tradition an attempt to go beyond the classical logic framework was made by Molinists in the doctrine of Middle Knowledge. The problem of the will in Eastern patristics was thoroughly investigated by Maximus the Confessor, who affirms that free will, unlike freedom of choice, is not actuality, but a certain goal for a person.
Keywords:
free will, predestination, logic, Augustinism, Pelagianism, fatalism, Maximus the Confessor
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
References
Anselm of Canterbury (1997) “On the Harmony of the Foreknowledge, the Predestination, and the Grace of God with Free Choice”, transl. by V. P. Gaidenko, in Istoriko-filosofskii ezhegodnik. 1996, pp. 130–132. Moscow, Nauka Publ. (In Russian)
Augustinus. De gratia Christi et de peccato originali. Available in Latin at: http://www.augustinus.it/latino/grazia_cristo/grazia_cristo_1_libro.htm (accessed: 28.12.2020).
Benevich G. I. (2013) A brief history of “Providence” from Plato to Maximus the Confessor. St Petersburg, Russkaia khristianskaia gumanitarnaia akademiia Publ. (In Russian)
Bernard of Clairvaux (2001) “Concerning grace and free will”, in S. S. Neretina, L. V. Burlak, eds. Antologiia srednevekovoi mysli (Teologiia i filosofiia evropeiskogo Srednevekov’ia). In 2 vols, vol. 1, pp. 445–476. St Petersburg, Russkii khristianskii gumanitarnyi institut Publ. (In Russian)
Boethius (1990) “Consolation of Philosophy” and other treatises. Moscow, Nauka Publ. (In Russian)
Brilliantov A. I. (1998) Influence of eastern theology on western one in works of John Scotus Eriugena. Moscow, Martis Publ. (In Russian)
Calvin J. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Available at: https://www.reformed.org.ua/2/857/2/Calvin (accessed: 02.09.2020). (In Russian)
Chistiakova O. V. (2018) “Free will and divine predestination in eastern and western patristic in a context of Orthodox (soterological) and philosophical distinctions”, in Logos et Рraxis, vol. 17, iss. 2, pp. 6–15. (In Russian)
Florenskii P. A., priest (1996) Works. In 4 vols, vol. 2. Eds hegumen Andronik (A. S. Trubachev), P. V. Florenskii, M. S. Trubachev. Moscow, Mysl’ Publ. (In Russian)
Florovsky Georges, archpriest (1992) Byzantine Fathers of the 5th–8th centuries. 2nd ed. Moscow, Palomnik Publ. (In Russian)
Gaskin R. (1994) “Molina on Divine Foreknowledge and the Principle of Bivalence”, in Journal of the History of Philosophy, vol. 32, no. 4, pp. 551–571.
Grabmann M. (2007) Introduction to St. Thomas Aquinas’s “Summa theologiae”. Transl. from German by A. V. Appolonov. Moscow, Signum Veritatis Publ. (In Russian)
Gregory of Nazianzus, st (1994) “Epistle to Presbyter Cledonius”, in Gregory of Nazianzus, st. Collected works. In 2 vols, vol. 2, pp. 9–18. Sergiev Posad, Sviato-Troitskaia Sergieva lavra Publ. (In Russian)
Ivanova T. N. (2009) “Dilemmas of the West European Middle Ages in V. I. Gere’s historical concept”, in Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriia Gumanitarnye nauki, vol. 151, iss. 2, part. 1, pp. 145–156. (In Russian)
John Damascene (2002) “An accurate statement of the Orthodox faith”, in John Damascene. The source of knowledge. Transl. and comm. by D. E Afinogenov, A. A. Bronzov, A. I. Sagarda, N. I. Sagarda, pp. 156–227. Moscow, Indrik Publ. (In Russian)
Kane R. (2016) “Acting ‘of one’s own free will’: Modern reflections on an ancient philosophical problem”, in Logos, vol. 26, no. 5, pp. 103–130. (In Russian)
Karpov K. (2014) “Predestination Doctrines in medieval philosophic Theology”, in Academia, no. 1 (32), pp. 228–250. (In Russian)
Karpov K. V. (2009) Predestination and free will problem in the late medieval culture (Gregory of Rimini concept) . PhD Thesis in Philosophy. Moscow, Institut Filosofii RAN. (In Russian)
Larchet J.-C. (1996) La divinization de I’homme selon saint Maxime le Confesseur. Paris, CERF Publ.
Larchet J.-C. The Mode of Deification. Available at: https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/books/original/16069-Obraz-Obozheniya.pdf (accessed: 30.10.2020). (In Russian)
Leibniz G. W. (1984) Works. In 4 vols, vol. 3, Moscow, Mysl’ Publ. (In Russian)
Leviczkij S. A. (2008) The Tragedy of Freedom: Selected works. Moscow, Astrel’ Publ. (In Russian)
Lourie B. (2016) “Maximus the Confessor and his Chinese logic. Pondering on new published works by G. I. Benevich with coauthors”, in Volshebnaya Gora, no. 17, pp. 468–478. (In Russian)
Lourie B. (2017) On a free will a bit more formally. Available at: https://hgr.livejournal.com/2177551.html (accessed: 08.11.2020). (In Russian)
Lourie B. (2017) On a free will once again formally. Available at: https://hgr.livejournal.com/2178504.html (accessed: 08.11.2020). (In Russian)
Lourie B. (2018) “A freedom beyond conflict: The logic of internal conflict and the free will in Maximus the Confessor”, in Scrinium, vol. 14, pp. 63–74.
Lourie B. M. (2006) History of the Byzantian philosophy. The formative period. St Petersburg, Axiōma Publ. (In Russian)
Luis de Molina (2014) “The harmony of free will with gifts of Grace”. Transl. by V. L. Ivanov, in EINAI, vol. 3, no. 1/2, pp. 213–260. (In Russian)
Lupandin I. V. “Metaphysical Disputations” by Francisco Suarez and Origin of modern European Philosophy. Available at: https://refdb.ru/look/1462385-pall.html (accessed: 07.09.2020). (In Russian)
Martin Luther (1986) “On the bondage of the will”, in Erasmus of Rotterdam. Philosophical works, pp. 290–545. Moscow, Nauka Publ. (In Russian)
Maximus the Confessor (2006) “‘Ambiguities’ to John”, in Maximus the Confessor. “Ambiguities” in the works of Gregory of Nazianzus and Pseudo-Dionysius. Transl. from Greek and notes by archim. Nectarius, pp. 51–385. Moscow, Institut Filosofii, Teologii i Istorii sv. Fomy Publ. (in Russian)
Maximus the Confessor (2009) “To Marin, reverend presbyter”. Transl. by A. M. Shufrin, in Anthology of Eastern Christian theological thought. Orthodoxy and heterodoxy. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Moscow, St Petersburg, Nikeia Publ., Russkaia khristianskaia gumanitarnaia akademiia Publ. (In Russian)
Neretina S. S. (1995) “Abelard and features of medieval philosophizing”, in Abelard P. Theological treatises, pp. 5–49. Moscow, Progress, Gnozis Publ. (In Russian)
Paisius the Athonite (2002) The words. Vol. 1: With pain and love about modern man. Transl. from Greek by hieromonk Dorimedont. Moscow, Sviataia Gora Publ. (in Russian)
Popov I. V. (2004) “The idea of deification in the ancient Eastern Church”, in Popov I. V. (2004) Works on Patrology. In 2 vols, vol. 1: Holy Fathers of the Second to Fourth Centuries, pp. 17–48. Sergiev Posad, Sviato-Troitskaia Sergieva lavra, Moskovskaia dukhovnaia akademiia Publ. (In Russian)
Serzhantov P. (2010) “The so-called half-Pelagian disputes”, in Philosophy of Religion: The Almanac 2008–2009, pp. 449–453. Moscow, Iazyki slavianskikh kul’tur Publ. (In Russian)
Shmonin D. V. (2000) “Turn in a labyrinth: Luis dе Molina regarding free will”, in Verbum, no. 2, pp. 39–51. (In Russian)
Shmonin D. V. (2007) “Decoration of Spain”, in Suarez Francisco. Metaphysical Disputations. Transl. by G. V. Vdovina, pp. 18–71. Moscow, Institut filosofii, teologii i istorii sv. Fomy Publ. (In Russian)
Sidorov A. I. (1994) “Monumental creation of St. Maximus the Confessor”, in Maximus the Confessor. Writings. Book 2: Questions to Thalassius. Part 1: Questions I–LV. Transl. and comm. by S. L. Epifanovich, A. I. Sidorov, pp. 7–10. Moscow, Martis Publ. (in Russian)
Sofrony (Sakharov), archimandrite (2011) Elder Silouan. 3rd ed. Sergiev Posad, Sviato-Troitskaia Sergieva lavra Publ. (In Russian)
Stoliarov A. A. (1999) Free will as a problem of the European moral consciousness. History sketches: from Homer to Luther, Moscow, Greko-latinskii kabinet Iu. A. Shichalina Publ. (In Russian)
Suarez Francisco (2007) Metaphysical Disputations. Transl. by G. V. Vdovina. Moscow, Institut filosofii, teologii i istorii sv. Fomy Publ. (In Russian)
Thomas Aquinas (2006) Summa Theologica. Part 1: Items 1–64. Transl. by A. V. Appolonov. Moscow, Izdatel’ Savin S. A. Publ. (In Russian)
Thomas Aquinas (2007) Summa Theologica. Part 1: Items 65–119. Transl. by A. V. Appolonov. Moscow, Izdatel’ Savin S. A. Publ. (In Russian)
Trubetskoi E. N. (1892) Religious public ideal of the western Christianity in the 5th century. Part 1: A world view of St. Augustine of Hippo. Moscow, Tipografiia E. Lissnera i Iu. Roman Publ. (In Russian)
Trukhanov Mikhail, archpriest. Christian fasting apology. S. l. et anno. (In Russian)
Vasil’ev N. A. (1989) Imaginary logic. Selected works. Moscow, Nauka Publ. (In Russian)
Vdovina G. V. (2019) Intentionality and Life. Philosophical psychology of postmedieval scholasticism. Moscow, St Petersburg, Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ Publ. (In Russian)
Wright G. H., von (1992) “Logic and Philosophy in the 20th century”, in Voprosy filosofii, no. 8, pp. 80–91. (In Russian)
Zarin S. M. (1996) Asceticism according to Orthodox Christian teaching. Moscow, Pravoslavnyi palomnik Publ. (In Russian)
Downloads
Published
2022-12-22
Issue
Section
Research
License
Articles of "Issues of Theology" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
