Logic of theological debate in the Book of Job: Criticism of Maimonides’ interpretation in the Jewish biblical exegesis in the 14th century
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu28.2020.105Abstract
The article discusses the critical understanding of Maimonides’ interpretation of the Book of Job, representing a theological debate on Divine Providence. Maimonides ascribes certain assessments on this issue to Job and his friends, linking their opinions to some theological or philosophical schools of the 10th–12th centuries, developed in the context of Arabic culture. A number of Jewish exegetes, who were working in a diverse cultural context and were writing in Hebrew, such as Joseph Ibn Kaspi and Gersonides, considered this distribution of opinions an anachronism. Being Maimonidean followers, they nevertheless criticized the distribution of opinions between Job and his friends proposed in The Guide of the Perplexed. The main argument of this criticism was logic. We will discuss the origins of such an approach and analyze some nuances of logical solutions, suggested by Maimonidean followers, juxtaposing them with a range of problems touched upon in The Guide of the Perplexed in regards to the Book of Job. It will be stressed among others, that the interpretation of Gersonides, coming from his statement on the logical completeness of the solution of the question of Divine Providence in the Book of Job, can be justified by the means of modern formal logic.
Keywords:
The Book of Job, Divine Providence, exegesis, Maimonides, The Guide of the Perplexed, Joseph Ibn Kaspi, Gersonides, logic
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
References
Ben-Shammai H. (1997) “Kalam in Medieval Jewish Philosophy”, in Frank D. H. and Leaman O. (eds) History of Jewish Philosophy. London; New York, Routledge, pp. 115–148.
Cohen Mordechai Z. (2004) “Maimonides’ Disagreements with ‘The Torah’ and Talmud in His Interpretation of Job”, in Zutot: Perspectives on Jewish Culture, no. 4, pp. 66–78.
Cohen Mordechai Z. (2005) “Maimonides’ Literary Approach to the Book of Job and Its Place in the History of Biblical Interpretation”, in Shnaton: An Annual for Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Studies, vol. XV, pp. 213–264. (In Hebrew)
Cohen Mordehai Z. (2011) Opening the Gates of Interpretation: Maimonides’ Biblical Hermeneutics in Light of His Geonic-Andalusian Heritage and Muslim Milieu, Leiden: Brill.
Diesendruck Z. (1936) “Samuel and Moses Ibn Tibbon on Maimonides’ Theory of Providence”, Hebrew Union College Annual, no. 11, pp. 341–366.
Eisen R. (2004) The Book of Job in Medieval Jewish Philosophy. Oxford University Press.
Eisen R. (2006) “Joseph ibn Kaspi on the Book of Job”, in Jewish Studies Quarterly, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 50–86.
Feldman S. (1997) “Levi ben Gershom (Gersonides)”, in Frank D. H. and Leaman O. (eds) History of Jewish Philosophy. London; New York, Routledge, pp. 319–335.
Gershowitz U. (2008) “Medieval Jewish Biblical Exegesis: History and Perspectives of Research”, in Vestnik: International Journal for Jewish Studies, vol. 12, no. 30, pp. 118–140. (In Russian)
Glatzer N. N. (1966) “The Book of Job and Its Interpreters”, in Altmann A. (ed.) Biblical Motifs. Origins and Transformations. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, pp. 197–220.
Ibn Kaspi J. (1903) “Explanation of the Book of Job”, in Last I. (ed.) ‘Asara kelei kesef. Pressburg, vol. 1, pp. 135–159. (In Hebrew)
Ibn Kaspi J. (1903) “Short Commentary on the Book of Job”, in Last I. (ed.) ‘Asara kelei kesef. Pressburg, vol. 1, pp. 213–264. (In Hebrew)
Kasher H. (1983) “The Image and Views of Job in The Guide of Perplexed”, in Daat, no. 15, pp. 81–87. (In Hebrew)
Kasher H. (1988) “Joseph Ibn Kaspi’s Aristotelian interpretation, and Fundamentalist interpretation of the Book of Job”, in Daat, no. 20, pp. 117–125. (In Hebrew)
Kasher H. (1991) “Suffering without Sinning: The Meaning of the God’s Trial in The Guide of Perplexed”, in Daat, no. 26, pp. 35–41. (In Hebrew)
Klein-Braslavy S. (2000) “The Philosophical Exegesis”, in Saebø M. (ed.) Hebrew Bible/Old Testament; the History of Its Interpretation. Vol. I, part 2: The Middle Age. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, pp. 302–320.
Klein-Braslavy S. (2006) “Dialectic in Gersonides’ Commentary on Proverbs”, in Tarbiz, vol. 75, no. 3–4, pp. 467–499. (In Hebrew)
Klein-Braslavy S. (2011) “Dialectic in Gersonides’ Biblical Commentaries”, in Fontaine R., Glaser R., Leicht R. and Vetri G. (eds) Studies in the History of Cultureand Science: A Tribute to Gad Freudenthal. Leiden, Brill, pp. 303–321.
Klein-Braslavy S. (2016) “The Aristotelian Theory of Chance and its Application in Gersonides’ Biblical Exegesis”, in Aleph: Historical Studies in Science and Judaism, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 367–405.
Kravitz L. S. (1967) “Maimonides and Job: An Inquiry as to the Method of the More”, in Hebrew Union College Annual, no. 38, pp. 149–158.
Kreisel H. (2006) “Esotericism to Exotericism: from Maimonides to Gersonides”, in Kreisel H. (ed.) Study and Knowledge in Jewish Thought. Beer Sheva, Ben-Gurion University of Negev Press, pp. 165–183.
Levinger J. S. (1988) “Maimonides’ Exegesis of the Book of Job”, in Uffenheimer B. and Reventlow H. G. (eds) Creative Biblical Exegesis. Christian and Jewish Hermeneutics through the Centuries. Sheffield Academic Press, pp. 81–88.
Manekin Ch. H. (2008) “Ambiguities of Scriptural Exegesis: Joseph Ibn Kaspi on God’s Foreknowledge”, in Manekin C. H. and Eisen R. (eds) Philosophers and the Jewish Bible. Bethesda, MD: University Press of Maryland.
Manekin Ch. H. (2011) “Logic in Medieval Jewish Culture”, in Freudenthal G. (ed.) Science in Medieval Jewish Cultures, Cambridge University Press, pp. 113–136.
Nuriel A. (1986) “For the Concept of Satan”, in The Guide of Perplexed, Jerusalem Studies in Jewish Thought, no. 5, pp. 19–38. (In Hebrew)
Ralbag (Levi ben Gershom, Gersonides). (2012) “Commentary on the Book of Job”, in Y. Levi and M. Zuriel (eds) Perush Ralbag al ’Yiov we-Mishley (Gersonides’ Commentary on Job and Proverbs). Jerusalem, Mossad Harav Kook, pp. 9–268.
Rambam (Moshe ben Maimon, Maimonides). (1930) The Guide of Perplexed, transl. by Samuel Ibn Tibbon with comment. of Efodi, Shem Tov, Qresqas and Isaak Abarbanel. Warsaw, 1930 (facsimile: Jerusalem, 1960). (In Hebrew)
Rambam (Moshe ben Maimon, Maimonides) (2000). The Guide of Perplexed, Part I, transl. by М. Shneider. Мoscow; Ierusalim, Makhanaim i Моsty kul’tury Publ. (In Russian)
Nuriel A. (1986) “For the Concept of Satan”, in The Guide of Perplexed, Jerusalem Studies in Jewish Thought, no. 5, pp. 19–38. (In Hebrew)
Reines A. J. (1972) “Maimonides’ Concept of Providence and Theodicy”, in Hebrew Union College Annual, no. 43, pp. 169–206.
Rosenberg Sh. (1981) “On Biblical Exegesis in The Guide of Perplexed”, in Jerusalem Studies in Jewish Thought, no. 1, pp. 85–157. (In Hebrew)
Rosenberg Sh. (1981) “Logic, Language and Biblical Exegesis in Writings of Rabbi Joseph Ibn Kaspi”, in Halamish M. and Kasher A. (eds) Dat we-safa: maamarim be-filosopiya khelalit we-yehudit. Mif ’alim ’universitaim, pp 105–113. (In Hebrew)
Rosenberg Sh. (1996) “Job was a Parable: Philosophy and Literary Exegesis”, in Rappel D. (ed.) Meḥqarim ba-Miqr’a u-ba-Ḥinnukh muggashim le-professor Moshe Arend. Jerusalem: Touro Colledge, pp. 146–158. (In Hebrew)
Saadiah ben Joseph Al-Fayyumi. (1995) The Book of Beliefs and Opinions, transl. to Hebrew and comment. by Y. Kafih. 4th ed. Jerusalem, Sura. (In Arab and Hebrew)
Saadiah ben Joseph Al-Fayyumi. (1973) ’Iyov im tirgum u-perush ha-gaon rabbeynu, Saadiah ben Joseph Al-Fayyumi, maqor we-targum, tirgem la-‘ivrit, bi’er we-hekhin Y. Kafih [Commentary of the Book of Job, transl. to Hebrew and comment. by Y. Kafih]. Jerusalem, Hamaqor. (In Arab and Hebrew)
Sackson A. (2017) Joseph Ibn Kaspi. Portrait of a Hebrew Philosopher in Medieval Provence. Leiden, Brill.
Schwarz M. (1992) “Some remarks concerning Maimonides’ discussion of God’s Knowledge of Particulars”, in Link-Salinger R. (ed.) Torah and Wisdom: Studies in Jewish Philosophy, Kabbalah, and Halacha. Essays in Honor of A. Human. New York, Shengold, pp. 189–197.
Sirat C. (2002) A History of Jewish Philosophy in the Middle Ages. Мoscow; Jerusalem, Моsty kul’tury Publ. (In Russian)
Strauss L. (1963) “How to begin to study the Guide of the Perplexed”, in Moses Maimonides, The Guide of Perplexed (transl. by S. Pines). Chicago; London, The University of Chicago Press, pp. XI–LVI.
Stroumsa S. (2003) “Saadya and Jewish ’Kalam’”, in Frank D. H. and Leaman O. (eds) The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Jewish Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 71–90.
Stroumsa S. (2009) Maimonides in his World: Portrait of a Mediterranean thinker. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.
Tzeitkin Y. (2015) “The missing synopsis to Gersonides’ commentary on Job (MS Paris 251): in light of the development of his exegesis and its sources”, in Hebrew Union College Annual, no. 86, pp. 101–139.
Twersky I. (1979) “Joseph ibn Kaspi: Portrait of a Medieval Jewish Intellectual”, in Twersky I. (ed.) Studies in Medieval Jewish History and Literature. Cambridge, Mass., pp. 231–257.
Yaffe M. D. (1979–1980) “Providence in Medieval Aristotelianism; Moses Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas on the Book of Job”, in Hebrew Studies, no. 20/21, pp. 62–74.
Downloads
Published
2020-05-06
Issue
Section
The turns of Jewish thought
License
Articles of "Issues of Theology" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
